| Song | Artist | Year | Pick | Genre(s) |
| Baby Says | The Kills | 2011 | Willis | Indie Rock |
| Lost in the Supermarket | The Clash | 1979 | Gregg | Post Punk /Dance Punk |
| Make U Love Me | All Saints | 2016 | Willis | Pop R&B |
| Spring | Maria Somerville | 2025 | Gregg | Dreampop /Trip Hop /Ambient |
| Shadows | Au Revoir Simone | 2009 | Willis | Indie Pop / Dream Pop |
| Dance Hall Days | Wang Chung | 1982 | Gregg | New Wave /Electro Pop |
| I’ve Done All That I Can | Jay Armstrong Johnson (from Lifeline the Musical) | 2024 | Willis | Musical / Scottish Folk |
| Elephant | River City Extension | 2009 | Gregg | Folk Punk /Indie Rock |
| Dreamin’ | Will to Power | 1987 | Willis | Freestyle |
| Show You My Way | Chrome Sparks | 2011 | Gregg | Electronic /Experimental |
Song playlists are also available on these platforms: