| Song | Artist | Year | Pick | Genre(s) |
| Bill Murray | Phantogram | 2014 | Willis | Indie Rock |
| The Peak | Art School Girlfriend | 2025 | Gregg | Atmospheric /Electro /Dreampop |
| Sometimes I Miss You So Much | P.M. Dawn | 1995 | Willis | Alt Hip Hop + R&B |
| Why | Carly Simon | 1982 | Gregg | Electro /Soft Rock /Hip Hop |
| Your Light | Versus GT (Nosaj Thing & Jacques Greene) | 2025 | Willis | Electronic / Glitch Hop |
| Do it Rite | The Bilinda Butchers | 2020 | Gregg | Dream Pop /Softgaze |
| 99 Luftballoons | Kaleida | 2017 | Willis | Synth Pop |
| Three Rings | Grizzly Bear | 2017 | Gregg | Indie Rock /Psych Pop |
| Tugboat | Galaxie 500 | 1988 | Willis | Indie Rock / Dream Pop / Shoegaze |
| Every Shining Time You Arrive | Sunny Day Real Estate | 1998 | Gregg | Indie Rock /(Proper) Emo |
Song playlists are also available on these platforms: