| Song | Artist | Year | Pick | Genre(s) |
| (Don’t You) Forget About Me [Live at Live Aid] | Simple Minds | 1985 | Willis | Alt-Rock |
| My Only Love | Roxy Music | 1980 | Gregg | Prog Wave /Atmospheric Rock |
| Deep Sea Diver | The Albert Square | 2025 | Willis | Indie Rock |
| Dalliance | The Wedding Present | 1991 | Gregg | Post Punk /Indie Rock |
| The Base | Paul Banks | 2012 | Willis | Indie Pop |
| Meant to Be | Jack J + Linda Fox | 2025 | Gregg | Dreampop |
| Goodbye | Cannons | 2022 | Willis | Dream Pop |
| Ceilings | Local Natives | 2013 | Gregg | Indie Pop |
| Fantasy Girl | Johnny O | 1989 | Willis | Freestyle |
| Louder than Love (album version) | TKA | 1990 | Gregg | Freestyle |
Song playlists are also available on these platforms: