| Song | Artist | Year | Pick | Genre(s) |
| The Right Time [feat. Al Jardine & David Marks] | Brian Wilson | 2015 | Willis | Pop Rock |
| I Just Wasn’t Made for These Times | Beach Boys | 1966 | Gregg | Surf PopPscyhedelic |
| Before (Choir Version) | Blonde Redhead w/Brooklyn Youth Chorus | 2025 | Willis | Indie Rock + Choir |
| Left Side Clouded | The Sea and Cake | 2003 | Gregg | IndieAmbient Pop |
| Break Time / In the Factory | Hemlock Ernst | 2024 | Willis | Hip Hop/Rap |
| Drifting In and Out | Porcelain Raft | 2012 | Gregg | DreampopAmbient |
| Multi-Love | Unknown Mortal Orchestra | 2015 | Willis | Psych Rock |
| Messy Hair | TV Girl & George Clanton [Feat. Magdalena Bay” | 2025 | Gregg | Indie PopElectronic |
| Ministry | Karen O and Danger Mouse | 2019 | Willis | Dream Pop / Trip-Hop |
| Sweetness Follows | R.E.M. | 1992 | Gregg | Alternative |
Song playlists are also available on these platforms: