| Song | Artist | Year | Pick | Genre(s) |
| Voodoo | Chris Isaak & Silvertone | 1985 | Geoff | Rockabilly, Pop |
| Gimme Danger | Paul Banks | 2025 | Gregg | Indie |
| Never As Good As the First Time | Sade | 1985 | Geoff | Neo-soul, sophisti-pop |
| Cowboy Chloe | Kevin Krauter | 2018 | Gregg | Dreamy Pop |
| Never Get Enough | The Waterlillies | 1994 | Geoff | Pop |
| Pacifico | Night Tapes | 2025 | Gregg | Psych Soul/Trip HopDreampop |
| Better Off Without You | Lastlings | 2023 | Geoff | Dance/Electronic |
| Summer Blu | Sunni Colon | 2018 | Gregg | Retro Soul |
| Something About Us | Pomplamoose | 2022 | Geoff | Indie Pop |
| I Didn’t Mean to Turn You On | Robert Palmer | 1985 | Gregg | Dance New WaveSoul |
Song playlists are also available on these platforms: