| Song | Artist | Year | Pick | Genre(s) |
| Saturn 5 | Inspiral Carpets | 1994 | Willis | Madchester, Indie Rock |
| Howl | Black Rebel Motorcycle Club | 2005 | Gregg | Psych Rock, Indie Rock |
| Call For Love | Morcheeba | 2025 | Willis | Downtempo Dance/Electronic |
| Red Knife | Patrick Paige II | 2018 | Gregg | Psych Soul, hip hop |
| The Last High | The Dandy Warhols | 2003 | Willis | Psych rock, alt rock |
| Misspent Youth | Clap Your Hands Say Yeah | 2011 | Gregg | Indie Rock |
| Until the Morning | Munya feat. Kainalu | 2025 | Willis | Synth pop |
| Knock on Wood | Prefab Sprout | 1987 | Gregg | New Wave, Sophista-pop |
| Please Forgive Me | Mt. Si | 2020 | Willis | Dance/Electronic |
| I Hear You Now | Jon Anderson & Vangelis | 1979 | Gregg | Ambient Electronic / New Wave? |
Song playlists are also available on these platforms: