| Song | Artist | Year | Pick | Genre(s) |
| Genius of Love | Tom Tom Club | 1981 | Willis | New Wave, R&B Hip Hop? |
| The Other Days | Sally Shapiro | 2025 | Gregg | Italo Disco/Synth Pop |
| This is Just to Say | Frank Cruz and the New Deal | 2014 | Willis | Indie Folk Rock |
| This is the Sea | The Waterboys | 1984 | Gregg | Indie/New Wave/Folk |
| St. James Way | U.S. Girls | 2023 | Willis | Indie, Experimental Pop |
| Maude Hope | Giorgio Tuma + Laetitia Sadier (of Stereolab) | 2016 | Gregg | Dreampop/Easy Listening/New Age |
| Titanic | Σtella & Redinho | 2022 | Willis | Indie Pop |
| Put Your Number in My Phone | Ariel Pink | 2014 | Gregg | Indie Pop |
| You Once Told Me | Andain | 2012 | Willis | Electronic Pop |
| Note to Self | Badly Drawn Boy | 2020 | Gregg | Indie Rock |
This playlist is also available on these platforms:
